Saturday, April 20, 2019

3 Diagnostics of Palms

In the Oct 2017 edition of "Detective Dendro, the diagnostic sleuth", a park manager called up the detectives because one variety of palm at her park seemed to be green and healthy, and another variety of palm had some fronds that looked yellow even with what was claimed to be optimal maintenance. Phoenix dactylifera (date palm) is dioecious (having male and female parts on seperate trees) and the healthy variety is only male. However the variety in question is female, and they had allocated magnesium to their developing fruits, and there were insufficient amount for the leaves. Solution was to prune off inflorescence stalks before fruits start to develop, or increase fertilisation rate for female palms. Use a balance, palm-specific fertiliser at a rate specified on the label, and avoid overdosing, which could induce deficiencies in other nutrients.

In the Feb 2014 edition, the detectives were called over during winter, to look at a  palm (Archontophoenix cunninghamiana) with frizzled fronds, looking like there were withered and burnt. At first, one detective thought that it was obviously due to frost damage. But the park manager shared that the skateboard area near that palm was fairly new, and another detective asked where the construction workers washed out their cement trunk. After digging around the base of the palm for a bit, chuncks of concrete were revealed. The washed out concrete raised the pH to make a more alkaline soil, and that would generally tie up manganese and iron leading to deficiency. Manganese deficiency leads to frizzling and that is commonly referred to as frizzle top. That detective asked the park manager to try a palm-specific fertiliser with at least 2% manganese in sulphate form. She suggested to fertilise the rest of the plantings with general fertiliser to lower the pH.

'Frizzle top'

In the Aug 2013 edition, the detectives were at a beach and noticed a Phoenix canariensis (Canary Island date palm) at the roadside with lots of dead fronds in the crown. The palms showed signs of being maintained as their leaf bases were pruned. However, the same palm in a private backyard does not have browning fronds. Upon closer inspection of the fronds, one-half is dead and brown while the other half is still alive and green. One detective postulated that if one of the petioles was sliced open, the vascular tissue would be dark brown with a pink blush in the surrounding tissues, indicating the presence of Fusarium oxysporum. To be sure, the detective suggested to the city arborist to send a sample to a diagnostics lab. He also postulated that the arboriculture contractor, which city arborist said quoted him low prices, was the culprit. He further shared that Canary Island date palms are very susceptible to Fusarium wilt, which is frequently transmitted through contaminated sawdust and tree sap on saws. The spots that remain on the saw between cuts are easily transmitted onto another palm. Therefore with these palms, hand saws (blades can be sterilised) should be used and not chain saws. Nothing could be done for the palms now that it was infected with Fusarium wilt, as it is nearly 100% lethal. New date palms should not be replaced on the same spot, as they would likely be contracted with Fusarium wilt from the infected soil. The detective suggests to the city arborist that he replace the palms with any other kind of palm that is not Phoenix spp., as Fusarium oxysporum is fairly host-specific.



Sunday, April 7, 2019

Possibly of Decay in Trees Wounded by Decay-Detecting Drilling Devices

"The tiny drilling hole closes itself up without any damage to the tree."
- says almost everyone who have used a resistograph or IML-Resi (decay-detecting drilling devices).

A resistograph or IML-Resi is a tool for tree inspections that detect decay in trees, wooden playground equipment, utility poles, and structural wood of houses and bridges. This tool was initially developed for the tree care industry, but its uses has apparently expanded to a few other industries.

It uses a stainless steel drill needle that is 3mm in diameter (head), and 200mm to 1000mm long. When the drill needle is pushed into the tree by the device, the resistance of the wood to it is recorded on a printed graph (in older models) or displayed on a screen that is on the device. Usually two to four drill points were made at lower part of the trunk and trunk flare, and where there are signs of decay such as cavity or mushroom.

 Head of drill needle, note the brad point.

The users of this device would either say that the fibers of the wood closes the drilling hole as the drill needle was retracted, or that the drilling hole left by the drill needle is so small that it is virtually not visible. Or that the drilling hole could be covered by the tree's growth in one or two year's time. The hole may be an entry point for fungal decay, and further excabated by the wood shavings that retain moisture.

To digress a bit, bits of the wood would be sheared off to allow the drill needle to enter further. The friction between the wood and drill bit head would produce wood shavings, wear down the cutting edge, and the integrity of the drill needle as a whole [1].
To digress a bit further, a drill needle for PD-300 could cost S$30 per piece, excluding shipping.


From at least two studies, what they found did not indicate that decay-detecting drilling devices should not be used [2, 3]. Trees that were already suffering from decay within the trees had their "rot cone" extend temporarily when drilled [3]. The compartmentalising ability of the tree and the aggressiveness of the fungus (determined by inoculum potential and colonisation strategy) are of crucial importance [4]. The studies conclude that the use of invasive diagnostic devices are less serious than felling the tree, or to prune major branches and roots, which typically allows fungal decay to set in.

References:

1. Wear Behavior of Drill Bits in Wood Drilling Resistance Measurements:

E. Sharapov, X. Wang, E. Smirnova and J.P. Wacker 2018, Wear Behavior of Drill Bits in Wood Drilling Resistance Measurements, Wood and Fiber Sciences, 50(2), 2018, pp. 13

https://www.swst.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/wfs2678.pdf

2. Development of Decay in the Sapwood of Trees Wounded by the Use of Decay-detecting Devices:

Craig Hallam 2004, Development of Decay in the Sapwood of Trees Wounded by the Use of Decay-detecting Devices, Treenet Proceedings of the 5th National Street Tree Symposium: 2nd and 3rd September 2004

https://treenet.org/resources/development-of-decay-in-the-sapwood-of-trees-wounded-by-the-use-of-decay-detecting-devices/

3. K. Weber and C. Mattheck, The Effects of Excessive Drilling on Wood Decay in Trees,
http://www.arbormedics.com/PDF/PDFsample2.pdf, last accessed 7 Apr 2019.

4. Schwarze, F.W.M.R., Engels, J. & Mattheck, C. 2004, Fungal strategies of wood decay in trees. 2nd Ed. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg.